Old-Fashioned Homemade New England Baked Beans Recipe

In yesteryear a sign of the fall and winter months in Northern New England was often heralded with church dinners, usually consisting of Old Fashioned Homemade Baked Beans, Baked Ham, rolls, coleslaw, and homemade pies. The ladies of the church would get together and make many pans of delicious New England baked beans using locally grown dried beans from the fall harvest, salt pork or bacon from the fall livestock reduction, and often maple syrup from the backyard Maple tree or the local maple provider.

This tradition has somehow fallen by the wayside and the art of making nutritious baked beans at home has been replaced with a can opener and a can of Bush’s, Heinz, B&M, or Campbell’s baked beans. So for those of you who have an appreciation of natural, wholesome food and some patients, please revive the true art of making homemade New England Bake Beans. The following time-tested baked bean recipe is simply delicious. Enjoy!


2 lbs. of dried beans (Soldier, Navy, Jacobs Cattle, Yellow-Eyed, or Great Northern) Using a high-quality organic bean will provide a better-tasting final product. Organic Beans for Baked Bean recipe
Please rinse and pick over beans before using. Place these rinsed and picked-over beans in a LARGE container of cold water. The water should be more than double the depth of the beans in the pot as the beans will absorb a large amount of the water. Let the beans soak for 8 to 12 hours.
Drain and rinse beans. Place in a large stockpot and cover with water. Again, at least 3 inches above the beans. Bring to a boil and then gently boil until you can blow gently on the skin of the bean and the skin will start to pull away from the bean. Turn heat to very low and add 1 heaping tablespoon of Baking Soda to the water. Stirring constantly or this will foam up and boil over. Cook for another 5 mins on low keeping a close eye on the pot. (The baking soda takes most of the gas from the beans)

Drain and rinse the beans again. Make sure to rinse them well. Let drain while you combine:

1 1/2 cups Maple Syrup preferably amber or darker syrup is best
1/4 to 1/2 cup Brown Sugar
1/4 to 1/2 cup Molasses the Darker the richer flavor
1 1/2 teaspoons Dry Mustard
2 cups boiling water

bakedbeansbeforebaking-150x150Place in bottom of the baking dish, bean pot, or crockpot (6 quarts or larger):
1 Large Onion, Quartered (optional)
6 strips of bacon cooked and diced or 1/3 lb. salt pork sautéed lightly in pieces (optional)

bakedbeanscooked-150x150Add Beans and cover with Liquid Mixture. Bake at 350 Degree oven for about 2 to 3 hours or I start in Crockpot on Low for 6 hours and then finish in the oven for about 1 hour. Make sure the beans stay covered in liquid so they do not dry out. Test every 30 mins after the first 2 hours when baking or after 5 hours in Crock-Pot. Baked beans should be soft, not crunchy. Overcooked bean will be mushy.

Feature your business, contact us. New England Living Magazine.

Attractions | Inns | Resorts | Hotels
Rental Homes | Real Estate | Restaurants
Camping | Business | Classified

Back to Top

New England Vacations Homes Realtors Restaurants Attractions Lodging Inns Resorts spas

Contact NewEngland Living Magazine to Feature Your Business Marketing New England Business Vacations Homes Realtors Restaurants Attractions

Explore New England - New England Living Magazine
Ogunquit, Maine
St. Johnsbury, VT
Branford, CT
Holyoke, MA
Wolfeboro, NH
York, Maine
Stowe, VT
Wells, Maine
New London, NH
Naples, ME

New England Living Magazine Advertising

Shop Walgreens Online

Shop Online 24/7 Free World Mall
Masks Online

Royal Albert | Bone China, Tea Sets & Fine Gifts

Shop Wilsons Leather Today!

Castle Hill Resort Okemo Vacations

Shop Boston Red Sox Wear Gear and Gifts

Country Weddings

Secure Server WebHosting Hosting Packages